Costello Eye Physicians & Surgeons
Optometry • Herkimer, NY
About
Costello Eye Physicians & Surgeons, PLLC is a small ophthalmology practice based in Oneida, NY, with 9 employees. They offer advanced surgical and medical eye care from a team of ophthalmologists and optometrists and serve the Mohawk Valley region. If you need confirmation of a Herkimer office, you may want to contact them directly through costelloeye.com or LinkedIn.
Clinic Type
Optometry
Address
250 E State St. Herkimer, NY
Phone
(315) 894-3132
—
Opening Hours
Monday – Friday: 8:00am–5:00pm
Services Offered
—
Insurance & Payment
—
Languages Spoken
—
FAQs
Address:
250 E State St. Herkimer, NY
Photos
What Patients Say
Overall sentiment across review platforms: positive
- Healthgrades: 3.7 out of 5 stars (3 reviews)
- WebMD (Dr. Patrick Costello): 4.0 out of 5 stars (42 ratings with 23 reviews)
- WebMD (Dr. John Costello): 4.5 out of 5 stars (39 ratings with 24 reviews)
- LASIKScore: 5 out of 5 stars (Not explicitly stated)
Patients praise
- Excellent cataract surgery outcomes (many achieving 20/20 vision)
- Thorough and clear explanations of procedures and options
- Professional, caring, and compassionate bedside manner of physicians
- Friendly, efficient, and professional staff support
Common complaints
- Long wait times for appointments
- Issues with office organization and scheduling
"I recently had cataract surgery done on both eyes by Dr. Patrick Costello. If you are considering having cataract surgery, I would HIGHLY recommend him. You won’t be disappointed. Both of my surgeries were done at the Griffiss Surgical Center. Dr. Costello and his staff were great. They all showed professionalism, they were very caring and compassionate."
— WebMD (Patient Review)"The biggest drawback is office organization. Waiting an hour and a half for a ten minute visit doesn't seem too considerate to the patients - especially as so many are elderly."
— Birdeye (Patient Review)Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].
In the News
Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 11, 2026.
Comparing your options?
See other optometry clinics in Herkimer, or search the full directory by insurance, ratings, and more.