Rothaus, MD
Surgery • Oyster Bay, NY
About
Rothaus MD is a plastic surgery practice serving Oyster Bay, NY and the surrounding area from offices in Manhattan and Westchester. The practice offers facial surgery including rhinoplasty, facelift, and blepharoplasty; breast procedures such as augmentation, lift, and reconstruction; body contouring including liposuction and tummy tuck; and nonsurgical treatments including injectables, fillers, and skin rejuvenation therapies.
Clinic Type
Surgery
Address
Oyster Bay, NY (near NYC); office shown as RothausMD in NYC context
Phone
212.737.0770
—
Opening Hours
Not published — contact the clinic to confirm hours.
Services Offered
Team
Insurance & Payment
—
Credit cards, Cash, Check, Financing may be offered by practice
Languages Spoken
Pricing
Current Offers
New patient offers (unspecified)
FAQs
What procedures are offered?
Facial, breast, and body contouring procedures including rhinoplasty, otoplasty, neck lift, facelift, brow lift, blepharoplasty, chin augmentation, cheek implants; gynecomastia; breast augmentation, lift, reduction, reconstruction; liposuction; tummy tuck; mommy makeover; SmartLipo; body lift; arm lift; cellulite treatments; injectables.
Social Media
Photos
What Patients Say
Overall sentiment across review platforms: mixed
- RealPatientRatings (Dr. Mark Epstein): 4.8 (442 Reviews)
- US News (Dr. Mariel Eliza): 5/5 Patient Experience (32 Reviews)
- WebMD (Dr. Mariel Eliza): 4.5 (16 Ratings)
- Healthgrades (Dr. Lyle Leipziger): 5 Star Rating (98 reviews)
- RealSelf (Dr. David J. Pincus): 5.0 (82 Reviews)
Patients praise
- Generally high patient satisfaction and strong recommendation statements for specific nearby surgeons (e.g., Dr. Epstein, Dr. Leipziger, Dr. Pincus, Dr. Eliza).
- Positive staff/communication and supportive care are repeatedly mentioned in reviews.
- Reported successful outcomes/“life-changing” or excellent aesthetic results are a common praise theme.
Common complaints
- Billing transparency/receipt invoicing problems and unexpected fees are cited in a patient review of Long Island Plastic Surgical Group (Trustpilot).
- Some complaint themes include unresponsive billing/customer service when attempting to resolve billing issues.
"“Patients consistently praise Dr. Mark Epstein and his amazing, professional staff for providing an exceptional, comfortable, and painless experience.”"
— realpatientratings.com (Dr. Mark Epstein - Verified Reviews)"“First and foremost, my experience was marred by the facility's blatant disregard for transparent billing practices… revealing an inflated bill… and… finance charges… conveniently omitted until after the surgery.”"
— trustpilot.com (Long Island Plastic Surgical Group, PC review)"“Dr. Eliza nothing less than wonderful. She listens intently… takes her time explaining… I would highly recommend her services.”"
— doctor.webmd.com (Dr. Mariel Eliza overview/reviews)Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].
In the News
- Preservé by Motiva NYC & Long Island | Aristocrat Plastic Surgery — Sep 8, 2025
- Sculptra Nassau County - Collagen Stimulation Therapy Suffolk — Sep 9, 2025
- The Name Long Islanders Are Seeing on the Road to the Hamptons: Dr. David Pincus of Pincus Plastic Surgery — Jul 6, 2026
- The Art of Confidence: How Dr. David Pincus is Empowering Patients Through Modern Plastic Surgery — Nov 16, 2025
Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 11, 2026.
Comparing your options?
See other surgery clinics in Oyster Bay, or search the full directory by insurance, ratings, and more.